http://cities.expressindia.com/fullstory.php?newsid=210498
For Dalits in
State, it’s all in the surname
Express News Service
Gandhinagar November 22: Dalits are changing their surnames, so says a study by
a senior official of the state Social Welfare Department, highlighting the
contemporary social reality in the State. The study by Hasmukh Parmar, a deputy
director with the department, shows a maximum of 46.67 per cent respondents in
the 30-40 years age bracket reporting a change of surname. Among reasons for the
change, a high 30 percentage directly blamed the social denigration they faced
based on caste.
While working on his PhD thesis, Parmar had carried out the survey interviewing
about 800 respondents in the north and central Gujarat districts of
Surendranagar, Patan, Mehsana, Gandhinagar, Ahmedabad, Sabarkantha, Vadodara and
Kheda. A majority of respondents were service class individuals followed by
professionals like doctors, advocates, teachers, and engineers among others.
“The phenomenon itself is not new. Given our hierarchical system of castes, a
surname becomes an easy tool to place an individual thus institutionalizing
discrimination. The study that I carried out as part of a thesis only helps
delineate certain issues that can be directly addressed,” says Parmar, who also
published a book reporting his findings.
There are other interesting points. The phenomenon is limited to urban centers,
as in a small rural setting individual identities are difficult to hide; and
most of the respondents changed their surname in order to dissociate from the
negative implications of one’s caste-based surname.
In a sign of caste practices, 76 per cent respondents said they have been asked
about their caste directly during first interaction with strangers in buses,
trains or other social gatherings. “In Saurashtra region even now a conversation
sometimes begins with the question Kai Nathe Cho (What’s your caste)?” says
Parmar.
Respondents have even listed out reasons why they changed surnames. One is
social acceptability and better interaction by not disclosing one’s caste
identity. Some cited easier availability of private sector jobs, home loans,
rented accommodation, and even striking office friendships as benefits derived
after changing surnames.
Of the total respondents who changed names, 23.33 per cent had their new
surnames based on their villages of origin, followed by 13 per cent based on
profession. The rest chose new names from literature, other higher castes, or
borrowed from friends. Though Parmar himself concludes that the practice of
untouchability has more or less gone out of the social landscape, caste based
relations still rule the societal mindscape, and lead to ostracisation, and even
violence in some cases.
His suggestions: In government jobs use of surnames should be avoided; Dalits
should voluntarily give up the use of surnames and have surnames based on the
village of origin.